Lucy Blake's Weblog

NSW Sex Industry Laws are the Gold Standard…..

apparently… (yeaaay for Basil – a researcher who knows how to research and isn’t afraid to do ethical research, has the bollocks to publish it and talk to it despite political pressure!)

Perth sex workers cop raw end of the deal: survey

Tamara McLean

September 15, 2008

Sydney prostitutes enjoy the best health and welfare, ahead of their Melbourne and Perth colleagues.Sydney prostitutes enjoy the best health and welfare, ahead of their Melbourne and Perth colleagues.

Sydney prostitutes enjoy the best health and welfare and Melbourne sex workers fare the worst, but their colleagues in Perth will get the “rawest deal” if the new Liberal state government stands by its pledge to regulate the industry, experts have warned.

A new report to be presented at a major sexual health conference found that all three cities have a “thriving” sex industry, with nearly 400 brothels in Sydney, 160 in Melbourne and 40 in Perth.

Researchers said Sydney was the “highest risk” city for sexually transmitted infections, as it absorbs all the migrant sex workers from Asia, but instead it appeared workers are well protected by decriminalisation of the industry.

“What we found is that sex workers (in Sydney) are not frightened to seek proper health services because there are no legal issues stopping them,” said Basil Donovan, a professor in sexual health at the University of NSW, who led the survey of 600 sex workers.

Melbourne on the other hand was a vastly different story, with a decriminalised system that still requires brothels to register their workers so they can get monthly health check-ups.

“That might sound nice but it’s extremely expensive, unnecessary and an intrusion on these women’s bodies, and it scares women away from being registered at all, which drives the whole thing underground,” said Prof Donovan, who argues the law should be reformed.

“It is simply a stupid system that creates an underclass of hidden sex workers who may very well suffer much worse health outcomes, if we could even track them down to find out.”

In WA, the now-ousted Labor government recently ended a 150-year system in which all forms of sex work were criminal and controlled by police.

The report, to be presented at the conference on Wednesday, showed that police have taken a protective role in recent years in a climate of imminent decriminalisation, allowing workers to openly seek health and welfare support.

But if the newly-installed state Liberal government follows through on its election promise to revert to the old system and implement a licensing scheme which tolerates some forms of government-controlled sex work, the situation will worsen dramatically, Prof Donovan said.

“Licensing is an even bigger joke than criminal laws,” he said.

“It’s never worked. The tools of trade, that is a woman’s body, are so portable and concealable, that any pretence to control it only leads to an artificial system that causes hidden prostitution and alienates workers from authorities. The new government would be crazy to go down that path.”

Janelle Fawkes, chief executive of the peak sex workers organisation Scarlet Alliance, echoed the call to end regulation of the sex industry, saying NSW laws were the gold standard in Australia.

Legal or not, sex industry powers on

Danny Rose

October 6, 2010

WHETHER prostitution is legal or not has ”little or no impact on the size of the industry” but it does affect the health of sex workers, Australian research shows.

A study of prostitution in Sydney, which has the most liberal approach; in Perth, where it is mostly outlawed; and Melbourne, which falls in between, has found a ”thriving” sex industry in all three cities.

Legal status was found to affect only the health and support services available to sex workers and the hygiene and safety standards of brothels.

// <![CDATA[// ”In spite of the different legal climates, each city had a thriving brothel, escort, private [call girl] sex industry plus a small street-based industry,” a co-author Basil Donovan, from the NSW and National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research at the University of NSW, said.

”On a per capita basis, the number of brothels was broadly comparable between the cities.

”This suggests the legal climate has no impact on the prevalence of commercial sex.”

Sex workers in Sydney, where adult prostitution is decriminalised and brothel locations are regulated through local planning laws, have access to the best-funded support program at $800,000 a year.

Sydney sex workers were also more likely to report regular contact with a health worker compared with those in other cities.

Sydney has about 200 brothels within 20 kilometres of the city centre, the research found, all operating legally – but many without planning permission.

But Professor Donovan said researchers had limited access to the city’s unlicensed brothels, which were likely to have poorer safety standards.

He said the research showed making prostitution illegal ”does not stop prostitution”, and it was a missed opportunity to improve health and safety.




Leave a Comment so far
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: